| Introduction
Lead from plumbing products may be leaching into drinking water. The amount of lead in drinking water depends on a number of factors, such as how much lead is in the plumbing parts, how large an area of a lead-containing part comes into contact with the water, how long the water is in contact with the lead-containing surface, and how corrosive the water is. Lead can be harmful to humans. Exposure to lead can cause serious adverse health effects, including delays in physical and mental development. In January 2009, California laws were enacted to increase protection of the public from exposure to lead in drinking water. This was done by reducing the amount of lead allowed in plumbing components. The intent of this legislation is to reduce the lead content in plumbing components intended to convey or dispense water for human consumption. DTSC’s January 2009 fact sheet provides detailed information on this issue. The test protocols provided in DTSC's August 2009 fact sheet are designed for DTSC to test and evaluate lead content of individual product samples acquired from locations that are readily accessible to the public at either retail or wholesale sources.
|
| Recent Legislation
|
| DTSC's Role
DTSC’s role in implementing the portions of the legislation related to sampling and testing consists of: 1. Evaluating and selecting reliable and adequate test methods, protocols and sample preparation procedures; 2. Coordinating with the plumbing manufacturing industry and providing information on testing protocols; 3. Annually testing, to the extent that resource are available, up to 75 faucet, fitting, and/or fixtures samples to determine compliance with "lead-free" standards; 4. Posting the testing results on DTSC's Web site and transmitting them to the California Department of Public Health (DPH); and 5. Coordinating with DPH on regulatory issues.
|
| Regulatory Background
Federal law -- Section 1417 of the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA) [Section 300g-6 of 42 U.S. Code (USC)]-- requires that after June 19, 1986, only "lead-free" pipe, solder or flux may be used in the installation or repair of (1) public water systems or (2) any plumbing in a residential or non-residential facility that is connected to a public water system and provides water for human consumption. "Lead free," as defined in the SDWA, means that the maximum allowed concentration is • 0.2 percent in solder and flux; • 8.0 percent in pipes and pipe fittings; In addition to the 8.0 percent limitation on lead content, certain plumbing fittings and fixtures must meet with standards established in accordance with section 1417(e) of the SDWA. As discussed further below, federal law requires that plumbing fittings and fixtures must comply with the standards contained in NSF Standard 61, section 9. A National Primary Drinking Water Regulation (NPDWR or primary standard) is a legally- enforceable standard that applies to public water systems, given the authority by SDWA. Existing California law (HSC section 116875) prohibits: • Any person from using any pipe, pipe or plumbing fitting or fixture, solder, or flux that is not "lead free" in the installation or repair of any public water system or any plumbing in a facility providing water for human consumption, except when necessary for repair of leaded joints of cast iron pipes; • Any person from introducing into commerce any pipe, pipe or plumbing fitting, or fixture that is not "lead free," except for a pipe that is used in manufacturing or industrial processing; • Any person engaged in the business of selling plumbing supplies, except manufacturers, from selling solder or flux in the business that is not "lead free;" • Any person from introducing into commerce any solder or flux that is not "lead free" unless the solder or flux has a label stating that it is illegal to use solder or flux in the installation or repair of any plumbing providing water for human consumption. Under existing law, HSC section 116875 defines "lead free" to mean that the maximum allowed lead content is: • 0.2 percent lead in solder and flux; • 8.0 percent lead in pipes and pipe fittings; • 4.0 percent lead by dry weight in plumbing fittings and fixtures. State law also requires all pipe, pipe or plumbing fittings or fixtures, solder, or flux to be certified as being in compliance with HSC section 116875 by an independent American National Standards Institute (ANSI) accredited third party. Further, under HSC section 25214.4.3, DTSC is required, based on available resources, to conduct lead plumbing monitoring testing, and annually collect field samples for testing and evaluation. The results of testing and evaluation are required to be posted on the DTSC Internet Web site, and transmitted to California Department of Public Health. As of January 1, 2010, some of the lead content limits described above are required to be further reduced. Beginning January 1, 2010, HSC section 116875 redefines "lead free" to mean that the maximum allowed lead content is: • 0.2 percent lead in solder and flux; • 0.25 percent lead in wetted surfaces of pipes, pipe fittings, plumbing fittings and fixtures, as determined by a weighted average. For all purposes other than manufacturing, industrial processing, or conveying or dispensing water for human consumption, the definition of "lead free" remains consistent with federal requirements: • 0.2 percent lead in solder and flux; • 8.0 percent lead in pipes and pipe fittings; • 4.0 percent lead by dry weight in plumbing fittings and fixtures.
|
| Fact Sheets
|
| Frequently Asked Questions
|
| Q. |
How could lead get into my drinking water?
|
| A. |
Lead gets into water after water leaves your local treatment plant or well. The source of lead in your home's water is most likely corrosion of the pipes or solder in your home's own plumbing. Corrosion results from a reaction between the water and the plumbing parts. Dissolved oxygen, low pH (acidity) and low mineral content in water are common causes of corrosion. One factor that increases corrosion is the practice of grounding electrical equipment (such as telephones) to water pipes. Any electric current traveling through the ground wire will accelerate the corrosion of lead in pipes. Eliminating the lead content in your home plumbing is an effective control of lead in drinking or cooking water.
|
| Q. |
Which products are affected by the changes to the law that are effective January 1, 2010?
|
| A. |
Beginning January 1, 2010, the law requires pipes and pipe fittings, plumbing fittings, or fixtures, and any other end-use devices intended to convey or dispense water for human consumption through drinking or cooking to meet the new "lead-free" definition. Examples include kitchen faucets, bathroom faucets and drinking water fountains. Service saddles, back-flow preventers for non-potable services such as irrigation and industrial, and water distribution main gate valves that are two inches in diameter and above are not covered by the law.
|
| Q. |
Where can my plumbing products get certified?
|
| A. |
A certification must be issued by an independent American National Standards Institute (ANSI) accredited third party, including but not limited to, NSF International (NSF). For the full list and more information of ANSI accredited third party, please click the link for ANSI’s website. |
| Q. |
Will any monitoring program be set up?
|
| A. |
The January 2009 law establishes a testing program for the lead content in plumbing products. HSC section 25214.4.3 requires DTSC, based on available resources, to annually collect up to 75 drinking water faucets or other drinking water plumbing fittings and fixtures for testing and evaluation. The law requires the results be posted on DTSC’s Web site and to be transmitted annually to the California Department of Public Health. |
| Q. |
Which products are excluded from DTSC’s annual testing and evaluation program required by HSC section 25214.4.3?
|
| A. |
While HSC section 25214.4.3 does not specifically exclude any product(s) from being subject to the testing and evaluation requirements, it does tie the testing program to those items subject to HSC section 116875. HSC section 116875 provides that the following items that are not subject to its requirements:
· service saddles;
· back-flow preventers which protect/separate potable water systems from non- potable services such as irrigation, industrial and laboratory use;
· water distribution main gate valves that are two inches in diameter and above; and
· pipes, pipe or plumbing fittings, or fixtures that used in manufacturing, industrial processing, for irrigation purposes, and any other uses where the water is not intended for human consumption through drinking or cooking
Assembly member Wilma Chan, the author of Assembly Bill 1953 (Chapter 853, Stats. 2006), which codified the low lead requirements for plumbing products, has published additional guidance about what she intended to be subject to the low lead requirement. Essentially, Assembly member Chan emphasized that the program was aimed only at those items that can reasonably bedescribed as intended to convey or dispense water for human consumption. Therefore, based on the plain language of the statute, the legislative history, and Assembly member Chan’s letter, DTSC’s initial rounds of sampling for its testing program will aim at those items that can reasonably be described as intended to convey or dispense water for human consumption through drinking or cooking.
|
| Q. |
Will DTSC develop a list and release it to the public indicating which products will be included in DTSC’s testing and evaluation program?
|
| A. |
No. Health and Safety Code section 25214.4.3 does not direct DTSC to establish such a list prior to sample collection. Based on the language of the statute, the legislative history, and the available resource, DTSC will exercise its own judgment on which product type will and will not be evaluated in the initial rounds of sampling and testing program. Further, DTSC will continue to evaluate for inclusion in its monitoring sample population any device which would be reasonably described as intended to convey or dispense water for human consumption through drinking or cooking. |
| Q. |
Has DTSC developed a protocol for testing plumbing materials?
|
| A. |
Yes. Health and Safety Code section 25214.4.3 requires DTSC to use test methods, protocols, and sample preparation procedures that are adequate to determine total lead concentration in a drinking water plumbing fitting or fixture to determine compliance with the lead content standards. In the August 2009 fact sheet “Testing and Evaluation of Lead Content in Plumbing Products, Materials, and Components”, DTSC outlined the testing protocols for lead content analysis in drinking water faucets and other drinking water plumbing fittings and fixtures that DTSC will use in its lead plumbing monitoring program. The analytical procedures for determining lead content percentage (as set forth in Section 2 of the August 2009 fact sheet) was used by DTSC during a round-robin study, in which nine laboratories, including DTSC’s Environmental Chemistry Laboratory, participated to evaluate laboratory procedures for lead content analysis.
|
| Q. |
As a third party certifier, should I use the lab protocol document DTSC recently posted on its website for lead-free certification?
|
| A. |
California law requires certification for pipe, pipe or plumbing fittings or fixtures, solder, or flux by an independent American National Standards Institute (ANSI) accredited third party, which includes, at a minimum, testing of materials in accordance with DTSC protocols. (HSC, § 116875(g.).) DTSC’s August 2009 fact sheet identifies certain analytical methods for lead content analysis DTSC will use during its monitor program, but recognizes equivalent analytical methods to be used. Third party testing organizations can use these analytical methods to test or monitor plumbing products, materials and components during certification process for lead content analysis. |
| Q. |
How will DTSC’s testing and evaluation program apply to plumbing fittings or fixture repair and replacement parts?
|
| A. |
The new lead content requirements apply broadly to all pipes, pipe fittings or plumbing fittings, or fixtures intended to convey or dispense water for human consumption. (Health and Safety Code, § 116875, subdivisions (a) and (b).) The statute does not contain an explicit exemption for replacement parts from the new lead content requirements. Nor has the DTSC found any supporting information in the legislation or related materials for the notion that the California Legislature intended to exempt such a broad category of materials as “replacement parts.” To do so would mean that for years or even decades after the law’s adoption, no meaningful reduction in lead exposure from drinking water would occur. Moreover, as plumbing fixtures sit on retail shelves available for purchase in California, there is no distinction between “new” and “replacement” parts. They are the same.
If DTSC were to test a plumbing fitting or fixture replacement part, obtained from a readily accessible retail or wholesale location, DTSC would apply the lead content formula to the specific part to determine whether the part met the 0.25% weighted average lead content standard. DTSC recognizes that applying the statutory lead content formula to individual replacement parts may result in replacement parts with a different lead content than the original equipment manufacturer (OEM) parts. However, this law was designed to gradually phase-out lead in plumbing parts as part of the normal replacement cycle for pipes, pipe fittings or plumbing fittings, or fixtures. To interpret the lead content formula to allow the use of lead containing replacement parts with a weighted average lead content above the statutory level would be contrary to that purpose. |
| Q. |
How is DTSC going to select up to 75 drinking water faucets and other drinking water plumbing fittings and fixtures to test and evaluate in its annual monitor program?
|
| A. |
Health and Safety Code section 25214.4.3 requires DTSC to exercise its judgment regarding the specific drinking water plumbing fittings or fixtures to test. The law also does not require DTSC’s selection to be either random or representative of all available plumbing fittings or fixtures. We appreciate your input and will value your opinions in our decision-making process. We will continue our ongoing outreach efforts. DTSC is developing general sample collection strategy which will be posted on this web site. If you have specific ideas for priorities in the selection of samples to test in the year of 2010, please send your comments to leadinplumbing@dtsc.ca.gov. |
| Q. |
What will be the procedure upon DTSC posting its annual testing and evaluation results in its public web site? Will the manufacturer have an opportunity to respond and verify that the product is genuine and not a counterfeit?
|
| A. |
DTSC recognizes that there are issues of concern to manufacturers such as the authenticity of products tested, variability within and between material and product batches, and controls over distribution chains. DTSC will contact each manufacturer whose product was collected for sampling prior to posting its annual testing results. There will be a case-by-case determination by DTSC of the level of interaction with manufacturers, distributers, or retailers prior to posting results to ensure the authenticity of products tested. Health and Safety Code section 25214.4.3 also requires DTSC to transmit the testing results in an annual report to the California Department of Public Health. Due to the very specific and limited role given to DTSC by the statute, DTSC does not have any enforcement authority. |
|
|
| Other Resources
Annex F (2007): Revisions to the Evaluation of Lead, New Requirements for Lead to Further Protect Public Health Annex G (2008): Weighted Average Lead Content Evaluation Procedure to a 0.25 Percent Lead Requirement - Code of Federal Regulations, Title 40 (40 CFR) Parts 141 and 142: National Primary Drinking Water Regulations (NPDWR)
|
| Contact Us
For inquiries about DTSC’s testing and compliance program, please e-mail to: leadinplumbing@dtsc.ca.gov Or send mail to: Dr. Xiaoying Zhou Toxics in Products Branch, 11th Floor Office of Pollution Prevention and Green Technology Department of Toxic Substances Control P.O. Box 806 Sacramento, CA 95812-0806 To receive Lead in Plumbing updates, please subscribe to our Lead in Plumbing Listserv.
| |